Where To Order a Perfect Pie For Thanksgiving

Pies are the comfort foods of desserts. They are the sweet ending to a wonderful Thanksgiving feast. Whether you want to bring a pie to a dinner you are attending or if you’re hosting and want to lighten your load, there is an abundance of delicious Thanksgiving pies to enjoy in our area:

thanksgiving pies
The Pie Store’s Chocolate Mousse Pie

Watchung Plaza’s The Pie Store will still be baking delicious pies, but this year will be order-only and will not have walk-in pies available for pick-up. That means you have to order ahead if you want a Brandied Pumpkin Pie, Coconut Custard Pie with Whipped Cream, and — one of my favorites — Chocolate Mousse Pie with Whipped Cream, as well as several other varieties. Pies from $11.95-$29.95.

Thanksgiving sweet potato pie
In The Company of Yum

In the Company of Yum is a Pop-up Bakery specializing in pies and other treats. Thanksgiving pie orders are being taken until November 20. You can order Sweet Potato Pie, Harvest Pie, Browned Butter Pumpkin, Caramel Apple Crunch, and many more. ($18 – 30) Orders can be made online here.

Thanksgiving pies
Gina’s Bakery

Gina’s Bakery on Walnut Street can take your pie orders through Sunday, November 22. Choose from apple, blueberry, cherry, mixed berry, pecan and pumpkin pies ($20 -$24.50).

thanksgiving pies
Little Daisy Bake Shop

The Little Daisy Bake Shop in Upper Montclair is offering Double Crust Apple, Apple Pie, and and Pumpkin Pie this year. Pies are $20-$30 and orders must be placed by November 15.

thanksgiving pie

Tiny Elephant in Montclair has pumpkin and apple pies available in their Thanksgiving catering menu. ($20) Orders must be place by November 19.

Cupcakes by Carousel

Cupcakes by Carousel on Church Street offers homestyle Thanksgiving pies — pumpkin, pumpkin cheese, apple, coconut, pecan, custard and blueberry crumb. Order pies from the Carousel Cakes website  by the November 10 and get 15% off.  Pies (10 inch) start at $12.

Nicolo's Italian Bakery & Deli
Nicolo’s Italian Bakery & Deli

Nicolo’s Italian Bakery & Deli in Montclair, known for great bread, will offer Pumpkin, Wheat, apple and more for Thanksgiving. Pies are $10-$14)

Plum Bakery 100% Gluten free
Plum Bakery

For those looking for gluten-free pies, Plum Bakery in Montclair is the place to go. Order pumpkin, pecan, apple crumb, coconut custrad,cranberry apple crumb or key lime in either 4 inch or 8 inch size. Orders must be places by November 19. ($8 – $32)

thanksgiving pieAnd if you like to bake, here are some great pie recipes to try:


  1. You forgot Anthony’s Cheesecakes on Washington Street in Bloomfield for his delicious Pumpkin Cheesecake, Carrot Cake Cheesecake and his Salted Pecan Cheesecake along with his Apple and Sweet Potato pies.


Comments are closed.