Love It or Hate It, Everyone Is Talking About This New York Times Essay About Montclair

BY  |  Monday, Mar 20, 2017 8:00am

Maybe you saw it in the paper or a friend shared it on Facebook, but if you haven’t read the essay Suburban? Just Don’t Call Her a ‘Jersey Girl’, just know that it rings true for some of Montclair and strikes the wrong chord for others.

The writer, Jodi Rudoren, raves about the town as a “city person’s suburb” and gives love to Montclair’s housing stock, farmers market and its “at least three distinct, equally adorable commercial districts, at least a dozen places to have brunch and probably twice that many nail salons, plenty of restaurants that deliver — though not 24 hours a day…”

Yet, the controversy comes from this paragraph:

And I did cringe when my brother-in-law, who raised his children in quintessentially suburban Short Hills, N.J., referred to my daughter as a “Jersey Girl.” When people ask where we’re from and the children answer “New Jersey,” I find myself correcting them: “Montclair.”



The reaction to the essay highlights what people often describe as two Montclairs — in this case, the people who were either born in Montclair or in other towns in New Jersey and those that came here from Brooklyn or Manhattan.

Give it a read and tell us which camp you are in…

Comments are closed.

Featured Comment

Sad. Let's hope that this is not its "Last Tango." One of the most beautiful and iconic buildings in town. Valentino, Garbo, Keaton must have played there.

Tip, Follow, Friend, Subscribe