Some people feel like turkey is the star of the show on Thanksgiving, but for many people, it’s all about dessert! If you’re looking to order some delicious after dinner treats for your holiday celebration, check out some of these local favorites!
In the Company of Yum will offer a variety of pies for the holiday. The Thanksgiving menu includes classics like traditional Apple, Pumpkin, and Sweet Potato, as well as specialties such as Cinnamon Roll Apple, The Man Pie, and Biscoff Cookie Creme. You can also order the Mini Pie Sampler or the Pie Jar Sampler. Orders will be taken until Sunday, November 21.
Plum Bakery (179 Glenridge Avenue, Montclair) continues to offer their gluten free Thanksgiving desserts. Place your order by Saturday, November 20. Pie varieties include Pecan, Apple Crumb, Cranberry Apple Crumb, Coconut Custard, Pumpkin, and Key Lime. Cakes, breads, and other baked goods are also available to round out your gluten-free holiday meal.
Nicolo’s Italian Bakery (6 Baldwin Street, Montclair) will have Apple, Cherry, Blueberry, Pecan, and Pumpkin pies available for Thanksgiving orders. Also available Italian sesame cookies, chocolate chip cookies with almonds and walnuts, and sfogliatelle. They will also have their regular selection of breads and menu items available to order as well. Place your order by Tuesday, November 23.
Montclair Bread Co. (113 Walnut Street, Montclair) will have a variety of desserts, doughnuts, and breads available to order. Orders must be received by Thursday, November 18. Pies include Pumpkin, Pecan, Apple Cranberry Galette, or Apple Crumb. Also available is an assortment of breads including pumpkin brioche and rosemary sourdough, as well as doughnuts, and other goodies are also available. Orders will be available for pickup on Wednesday November 24 and Thursday November 25. Pies start at $32.
The Little Daisy Bake Shop (622 Valley Road, Montclair) will be offering Pumpkin and Apple Crumb pies will be available in limited quantities. Call to place pie orders with pickup on Tuesday, November 23 or Wednesday, November 24.
Anthony’s Cheesecake (71 Washington Street, Bloomfield) has many desserts available for preorder. The selection includes cheesecakes like New York Style, Pumpkin, Salted Caramel Pecan, pies such as Pumpkin, Pumpkin Cream Cheese, Apple Crumb, and Brookie, plus layer cakes. The store will be open until 12:00 PM on Thanksgiving Day.
Mattarello Bakery & Café (254 Bellevue Avenue, Montclair) is offering a selection of desserts and pastries. Choose from classics like Pumpkin, Pecan, and Apple. Also available are cannoli, lobster tail, sfogliatella, macarons, and more. Place your order online.
Faubourg (544 Bloomfield Avenue, Montclair) has desserts to go as part of their Thanksgiving at Home offerings. Pie selections include Pumpkin, Apple, and Pecan. You can also order ice cream and sorbet. Choose three pints for $30. Available flavors are vanilla, chocolate, pistachio, for di latte, coffee, salted caramel, raspberry, lemon, and mango. Orders must be placed by Friday, November 19.
Pure Love Pies (1042 Broad Street, Bloomfield) is offering a wide selection of pies and more, including their famous Navy Bean Pie, butternut squash pie, coconut custard, and more. Also available are peach cobbler, banana pudding, and cookies. Order online and allow at least 24 hours prior to pick up.
Sweet Kitchen Montclair (533 Bloomfield Avenue, Montclair) has desserts available to order for the holiday. Choose from Apple, Pumpkin, or Pecan Pie, Pumpkin Cheesecake, and Sticky Toffee Pudding. Two packages of assorted desserts are also available, one for 12-15 people and one for 8-10 people. Both include a selection of mini desserts. Place your order by 3:00 PM on Tuesday, November 23.
If you’re prefer to try your hand at a homemade dessert, check out these recipes!